Human Nature Critique Essay - 1238 Words

Michael E. Castillo Armstrong Rhet/Comp II October 1, 2014 Human Nature Critique In his article, Human Nature, investigative historian Mark Dowie argues the fact that people’s ideas of what nature and wilderness completely invalidate the true meaning of what nature really is. His main claim is that the western way of thinking about wilderness and nature as separate from humanity has led to environmental destruction and ethnic cleansing. In the beginning of the article, Dowie introduces the way these different photographers have created a myth of nature through their pictures of places that are absent of humans to give society a distorted interpretation of what nature is or looks like. He continues his article by involving†¦show more content†¦Based on who William Cronon is, Dowie is given the opportunity of obtaining credibility for his argument by utilizing Cronons essay and allowing it to support his ideas clearly. Along with the testimonies that Dowie uses to help advocate his deliverance of his argument, the interviews he conducts with different people also grant Dowie more credibility for his essay and argument. As a way to provide to these ideas, he uses interviews to state his claim that nature is really everything we live in, not something we separate from ourselves and call nature. Dowies interview with Patricia Cochran, a Yupik native scientist in Alaska, implies just that. Cochran says to Dowie in the interview that they have no word for wilderness, and What you call wilderness we call our back yard. This perfectly advocates Dowies idea that everything we live in is called the wilderness, or nature. In the continuing interviews, each person continues to introduce the same belief. Jakob Malas, a Khomani hunter, states that what he lives in is not wilderness to us. The same follows with each interview, each with the same or a similar response to whatever question Dowie asks. The use of t he interviews in Dowie’s article are possibly the most important aspect for Dowie to have his argument statedShow MoreRelatedThe Seventh Chapter of Romans1139 Words   |  5 Pagesmeaning. It might be seen as offering up a very low anthropology, and a pessimistic view of the human condition. Even the central question of who is thought to be speaking in the majority of the chapter remains a hotly contested question. Nevertheless, in the face of perceived ambiguity, the speaker of Romans Chapter 7 offers an insight into the deep schism of action and thought that is found in each human mind, which can only be escaped through the grace and power of God. To understand Paul’s thinkingRead MorePhilosophical Argument ( 400 Words )844 Words   |  4 PagesPHILOSOPHICAL ARGUMENT (400 words) According to Sartre (1948, p.1) Existentialism is a principle that renders human life possible, through the affirmation that all truth and action denote an environment and a human subjectivity. A belief that the essence of man precedes that existence which we encounter through experience (Sartre, 1948, p. 3). Existentialism places the full responsibility for one’s existence upon our own shoulders; putting a man in ownership of himself as he is, responsible forRead MoreInnate Sin of Selfishness1400 Words   |  6 Pagesinto the nature of sin and prescribe solutions to problem of evil so that Christians can understand the existence of evil. Human nature defined by both Paul and Augustine is the pattern drawn from actions that humans without a stimulus. For Paul, the importance of love, and condemnation of the idea that all is permitted reveal his view of human nature. Augustine’s analysis of infancy and of his own sexual urges leads to a similar view of human nature. Bot h Paul and Augustine view the nature of humansRead MoreA Reflective Paper On Integration852 Words   |  4 Pagessuffering guilt or shame and their confession will then require a process for helping. The Spirit of Truth must be central in that decision and thus the use of Christian Psychology is my current integrative position. Historic Foundation Understanding human beings according to historic Christianity is a foundation of this view (Johnson, 2010 p. 155). There is evidence of psychology embedded in the wisdom of Scripture, as in Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount and throughout the New Testament for Jesus’ dealingRead MoreEssay on Nature vs Nurture in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein2036 Words   |  9 Pages Philosophers and scientists alike have debated for centuries whether a person’s character is the result of nature or nurture. In the writings of Thomas Hobbes, it is expressed that humans are endowed with character from birth, and that they are innately evil in nature. John Locke’s response to this theory is that everyone is born with a tabula rasa, or blank slate, and then develops character after a series of formative experiences. The idea that true character is the result of experiences and societalRead MoreAnalysis Of Sartre s The Wall870 Words   |  4 Pagesdeath. Consequently, Sartreà ¢â‚¬â„¢s critique of the nature of the universe and nature of man is viewed through the lens of one who is anticipating death. In The Wall Sartre makes an indirect comment about happiness by depicting the void of happiness that can reside in the anticipation of death. Despite deaths interconnection with the nature of the universe and life, Sartre most direct comment on the basic philosophical –religious questions of life is concerning human nature. Thus, I will begin this previewRead MoreMorality via Kant and Hegel1712 Words   |  7 Pages1. Introduction Human beings have moral inclinations that affect our actions. Few would deny as a fact of human life a perpe-tual strive to do right and good concordant with one’s particular moral beliefs (while concomitantly judging others by them). For most, this strive is accompanied by a questioning of the very nature of the moral: Is there an impartial criterion that enables us to know objectively what one ought to do, or do our moral intuitions rest solely on subjective, arbitrary groundsRead MoreThe Philosophy Of Criticism : The Ontological, Psychological, And Pedagogical800 Words   |  4 Pagesnot only challenge their mind but are encouraged to use their mind in order to challenge. For example, Plato develops three critiques: the ontological, psychological, and pedagogical. The ontological critique focuses on how the imitations inspiration trickles down a â€Å"chain of magnets.† The Gods inspire a muse, and the Muse inspires the Rhapsode. (Explain) The first critique analyze s how the strength of inspiration isn’t lost but knowledge is. The Gods being ultimate knowledge, while the RhapsodeRead MoreAnalysis Of Avatar1353 Words   |  6 Pagesfrom its presentation of alien natives and a colonial corporate military, to race issues and a depiction of cigarette use. This essay attempts to explore main threads of the film, analyzing criticism, and offering its own critique and deconstruction. It will employ diagnostic critique, as well, in order to analyze how Avatar is equally a reflection of and an active influence on contemporary culture. Avatar takes place on the vibrant world of Pandora, created by Cameron with digital technology and colonizedRead MoreThomas Hobbes Social Contract Theory Essay895 Words   |  4 Pagescollective agreement where everyone in the state of nature comes together and sacrifices all their liberty in return to security. â€Å"In return, the State promises to exercise its absolute power to maintain a state of peace (by punishing deviants, etc.)† So are the power and the ability of the state making people obey to the laws or is there a wider context to this? I am going to look at the different factors to this argument including a wide range of critiques about Hobbes’ theory to see whether or not his